The costs of Indigenous and non-Indigenous offender trajectories


Reducing Indigenous overrepresentation in the criminal justice system is justified on both social justice and economic grounds. We developed an innovative costing framework and estimated direct criminal justice system unit costs based on critical cost drivers. These estimates were applied to offender trajectories, modelling offences of all individuals registered as being born in Queensland during 1983–1984 (from ages 10 to 31). Separate trajectory models were developed for Indigenous and non-Indigenous Queenslanders in the birth cohort to enable separate cost estimations for these groups. Findings identified over one-half (53%) of the identified Indigenous cohort and 16 percent of the non-Indigenous cohort had moderate to chronic offender trajectories. Because of the high levels of recontact and sanction seriousness and length, Indigenous offenders were on average more costly. These findings emphasise the high cost of current criminal justice system responses to Indigenous and chronic offenders in particular and the need to consider innovative and more cost-effective approaches to reduce offending by individuals in these groups.


URLs correct as at February 2024

Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) 2011. Australian and New Zealand Standard Offence Classification (ANZSOC) 2011. cat. no. 1234.0. Canberra: ABS.

ABS 2009. Estimates and projections, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians (ABS 3238.0).

Allard T 2011. Indigenous young people and the justice system: Establishing an evidence base. In A Stewart, T Allard and S Dennison (eds), Evidence based policy and practice in youth justice, 28–44. Sydney: Federation Press

Allard T 2010. Understanding and preventing indigenous offending. Research brief no. 9. Sydney: Indigenous Justice Clearinghouse.

Allard T, Chrzanowski A & Stewart A 2015. Integrating criminal careers and ecological research: The importance of geographic location for targeting interventions towards chronic and costly offenders. Crime & Delinquency. DOI: 10.1177/0011128714568187

Allard T, Chrzanowski A & Stewart A 2013. Targeting crime prevention: Identifying communities that generate chronic and costly offenders. AIC Reports: Research and Public Policy Series. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology.

Allard T et al. 2014. The monetary cost of offender trajectories: Findings from Queensland (Australia). Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology 47: 81–101

Allard T et al. 2010. Police diversion of young offenders and Indigenous over-representation. Trends & issues in crime and criminal justice no. 390: 1–6.

Allard T & Manning M 2011. Establishing an evidence base: Economic analysis. In A Stewart, T Allard and S Dennison (eds), Evidence based policy and practice in youth justice, 187-205. Sydney: Federation Press

Allard T, McCarthy M & Stewart A 2020. Costing Indigenous and non-Indigenous offending trajectories: Establishing better estimates to assist the evidence base and prevent offending. Report to the Criminology Research Council.

Allen R 2011. Justice reinvestment and the use of imprisonment: Policy reflections from England and Wales. Criminology & Public Policy 10: 617–627

Australian Government 2007. Best practice regulation handbook. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia

Australian Institute of Health and Welfare (AIHW) 2019. Youth justice in Australia 2017–2018. cat. no. JUV 129. Canberra: AIHW

Broidy L et al. 2015. Life-course offending pathways across gender and race/ethnicity. Journal of Developmental and Life-Course Criminology (1)2: 118–149

Clear T 2011. A private-sector, incentives-based model for justice reinvestment. Criminology & Public Policy 10: 585–608

Council of Australian Governments 2018. COAG statement on the closing the gap refresh. 12 December 2018. Canberra: COAG

Cohen MA, Piquero AR & Jennings WG 2010a. Monetary costs of gender and ethnicity disaggregated group-based offending. American Journal of Criminal Justice 35: 159–172

Cohen MA, Piquero AR & Jennings WG 2010b. Studying the costs of crime across offender trajectories. Criminology & Public Policy 9: 279–305

Day DM & Koegl CJ 2019. The monetary costs of criminal trajectories for a sample of offenders in Ontario, Canada. Journal of Developmental and Life Course Criminology: 5(2) 203–219.

Ferrante A 2013. Assessing gender and ethnic differences in developmental trajectories of offending. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology 46(3): 379–402

Haynie DL, Weiss HE & Piquero A 2008. Race, the economic maturity gap, and criminal offending in young adulthood. Justice Quarterly 25(4): 595–622

KPMG 2018. Maranguka justice reinvestment project: Impact assessment. Report for Maranguka and Just Reinvest NSW. Sydney: KPMG

Larg A & Moss JR 2011. Cost-of-illness studies: A critical guide to evaluation. Pharmacoeconomics 29(8): 653–671

Little S & Allard T 2011. Preventing reoffending: System responses. In A Stewart, T Allard and S Dennison (eds) Evidence based policy and practice in youth justice, 152-168. Sydney: Federation Press

Little S, Allard T, Chrzanowski A & Stewart A 2011. Diversion of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander young people in Queensland: The impact, use and alternatives to existing diversionary measures in addressing Indigenous over-representation. Report for Queensland Government.

Livingston M, Stewart A, Allard T & Ogilvie J 2008. Understanding juvenile offending trajectories. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology 41(3): 345–363.

Maldonado-Molina M, Piquero A, Jennings W, Bird H & Canino, G 2009. Trajectories of delinquency among Puerto Rican children and adolescents at two sites. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 46: 144–181

Moffitt TE 1993. Adolescent-limited and life-course persistent antisocial behaviour: A developmental taxonomy. Psychological Review 100: 674–701

Ogilvie J & Allard T 2011. Preventing reoffending: Therapeutic interventions. In A Stewart, T Allard and S Dennison (eds) Evidence based policy and practice in youth justice,134-151. Sydney: Federation Press

Piquero AR & Buka S 2002. Linking juvenile and adult patterns of criminal activity in the Providence cohort of the National Collaborative Prenatal Project. Journal of Criminal Justice 30: 259–272

Piquero AR, Jennings WG & Farrington D 2013. The monetary costs of crime to middle adulthood: Findings from the Cambridge study in delinquent development. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 50: 153–74

Productivity Commission 2018. Report on government services 2018. Canberra: Productivity Commission